Friday, 19 April 2013

Football Players and Field Collapses

So lately I’ve been doing a bit of reading on footballers who collapses on the pitch while playing football. It is a topic which has bothered me for quite some time and I wanted to find out what caused it.

Getty Images

We all remember that horrible moment when Fabrice Muamba collapsed at White Hart Lane during the FA Cup match between Tottenham Hottspur and Bolton on the 17th March 2012. I honestly do not think anyone can remove the image of him laying lifeless on the pitch surrounded by paramedics while the rest of the players and the supporters stood helplessly by.
According to reports from back then, Muamba stopped breathing on his own for two hours and was 'dead' for 78 min. Thankfully, Fabrice Muamba was one of the lucky ones, and one year later, he is alive and well.
Others, such as Antonio Puerta, Miklos Feher and Piermario Morosini were sadly not as lucky. (And I use the world luck, because that is really what separates Muamba from these other men.)
 
There seem to be a bit of a debate as to what actually caused these collapses and no one can actually tell for certain. There seem to be two main theories however;
  • It is caused by excesive training
  • It is due to undiagnosed heart conditions

If we start with the first one, we can see that some argue that collapses like these are due to too much pressure on the body, in the sense of too much exercise. According to an article posted on The Guardian, hypertrophic obstructive cardiomyopathy (HOCM for short) can be developed through extensive exercise. The heart takes a reshaped form, making it easier for it to adapt to the stress caused by all the hard training.
In most cases this reshaping of the heart is a good thing since it allows blood to flow through the veins around the body more effectively. However, it can develop to become HOCM, “a genetic abnormality that causes the muscle wall of the heart to grow far ticker than it should.”  What this means is that instead of letting the blood flow easily through the body, hinders it. If it becomes thick enough, it can stop the flow of blood going to and from the heart.
And so, suddenly, “an athlete with HOCM might seem very fit but the heart is struggling like that of an unwell 80-year-old," the article states.
The other theory has to do with heart conditions which are not discovered. A lot of specialists argue that the reason these athletes collapse is because there is an underlying heart condition which has gone unnoticed. Often these heart conditions are genetic, but not always.
Although HOCM can be developed, it is also a condition which is “one of the most common genetic cardiac conditions in human population,” say Dr. Chandan Devireddy to CNN. There can also be things such as “cardiac arrhythmia, where the rhythm of the heart is broken and a cardiac arrest occurs,” or it could be “the congenital abnormality of the structure of the coronary arteries, which a person would be born with – and which might not have been diagnosed,” Dr. Devireddy continues.
So what can be done to discover these heart conditions? Because do these footballers not undergo extensive medical tests?
The answer is yes, they do. However, sometimes these tests are not enough.
Arguably, athletes should undergo EKGs (interprets electrical activity), as well as ECHO cardiagrams (an ultrasound technique to create images of the heart).
However, the really scary part is; “With EKG screening, sometimes this (the heart conditions) isn’t caught. With the HOCM, about 70% of the first incidence of that being diagnosed is with a sudden cardiac death episode,” says Dr. Devireddy.
The Telegraph article on Fabrice Muamba and the Lazarus Effect also point to the importance of CPR (cardio-pulmonary resuscitation), as this should be one of the first actions to take when someone suffers from cardiac arrest. However, according to the article, “less than one third of cardiac arrest victims outside hospital receive CPR.”
Muamba, a year later, is now an active advocate for the British Heart Foundation, as well as the UK Resuscitation Council, wanting CPR to be incorporated into the school curriculum at a secondary level.
Though there still seems to be some ambiguity as to why these footballers collapse on the field, the important thing is really that it does happen. There is an obvious need to strengthen the medicals for athletes, and the importance of having a doctor on scene is key. 


As for you, me and Fred down at the pub, it might be wise to do some digging into the family medical history, just to be sure.


No comments:

Post a Comment